
Source: The Girl’s personal library
The Girl’s Rating: ★★★★★
The Girl (age 11) recently finished The Loser List: Revenge of the Loser by H.N. Kowitt (sequel to The Loser List) and wanted me to ask her some questions for her review. First, a little about the book:
My name, Danny Shine, is officially OFF the Loser List in the girls’ bathroom. But now I have a new problem: this guy, Ty Randall.
Ty is basically perfect, and he’s ruining everything — including my reputation as the best artist in the school. So I really have no choice. I have to get REVENGE. (publisher’s summary)
Me: Tell us a little about this book.
The Girl: This new guy, Ty, comes to school, and he grabs everyone’s attention, including Danny’s secret crush. And it’s about a talent show to raise money to renovate a playground, and they run into a lot of problems. Danny doesn’t like how Ty won the art contest instead of him, and now no one pays attention to Danny anymore.
Me: Did you like Revenge of the Loser better than the first book?
The Girl: I liked the first book a little better because the plot was more interesting. But I’d still give this book 4 out of 5 stars. I gave the first book 4.5 stars, though.
Me: How has the main character, Danny, changed since Book 1?
The Girl: He hasn’t really changed, but people are more interested in his drawings since the last book.
Me: What was your favorite scene in the book?
The Girl: When Danny catches Ty horribly rapping about global warming in the locker room. Ty doesn’t know he’s being watched. It was really funny.
“Global warming u gotta prevent it
Let’s all write postcards to the Senate….”This was the worst rap I’d ever heard! Being tone-deaf was bad enough. But now he was twitching with his thumbs turned out. I was staring so hard, I didn’t realize my backpack had slid down my arm. As I watched Ty strut, it dropped to the ground with a THUD! (pages 66-67)
Me: Do you think kids your age can relate to Danny, or is he a little over the top?
The Girl: I guess kids who like to draw and read comics could relate to him. I do because I like to read and write comics.
Me: Do you hope there’s a Book 3?
The Girl: Yes, I’d read another one of these books.
Me: Any last thoughts?
The Girl: Yes. This book made me laugh out loud during silent reading in class.
Me: Did you get in trouble?
The Girl: No. But other kids stared at me funny. 🙂
Disclosure: The Loser List: Revenge of the Loser is from The Girl’s personal library.
© 2012 Anna Horner of Diary of an Eccentric. All Rights Reserved. Please do not reproduce or republish content without permission.
This review made me laugh out loud! Since it made The Girl laugh out loud and she’d read another one in the series, this book must be good.
LikeLike
She couldn’t wait to get this one from the Scholastic Book Fair.
LikeLike
Don’t bring this one to silent reading time in class! Another fun review by The Girl. 🙂
LikeLike
Thanks, Suko!
LikeLike
I like how you ask if she got into trouble.
LikeLike
Hey, I’m her mom, I need to know these things. LOL
LikeLike
Any book that causes the reader to laugh out loud is a book worth reading! Keep the reviews coming The Girl!
LikeLike
Thanks, Kim!
LikeLike
I hate it when everyone stares at me when I start laughing at a book in public. I try and read serious books whenever I’m out of my house now, but I’d love to know if any of the other children in the class are interested in reading the book now they’ve seen The Girl laughing? Love the joint review – I hope my boys will be up for something similar in a few years 🙂
LikeLike
That would be great to see you review books with your boys! From what she told me, the book sold out quickly at the book fair. I’ll have to ask if any other kids her in class read it.
LikeLike
I’m all for books that make you laugh out loud in class. I’ve read a few of those in my day .. including during college?
LikeLike
I still read laugh-out-loud books, and I get strange looks on the train. But I have to live up to the eccentric name, so…
LikeLike
I love The Girl’s perspective on this series!! I will have to add this one to the collection!!
LikeLike
I hope your students love it as much as she did!
LikeLike
My daughter read the first book and liked it. This method of review (interview style) is really neat! I love reading The Girl’s reviews.
LikeLike
Thanks, Laura! I try to mix up the format a bit so that she doesn’t get bored with reviewing.
LikeLike